Does Morgan pursue the cash that might help him find a cure out west for his tuberculosis (spoiler: it won’t) or at least live like a king in his last few moments or does he abandon it, choosing to sacrifice himself to help Marston escape and return to his family? @BAMozzy "As a lead character in a 'story', I think that Marston wins but as a lead in a game, it probably works out more in Arthurs favour" Great point and I agree! The series gave fans two empathetic and fleshed-out heroes in John Marston and Arthur Morgan, with the former also being a playable character in the epilogue of RDR2. Arthur Morgan (RDR 2) Carl Johnson (GTA SA) John Marston (RDR) Niko Bellic (GTA IV) Red Harlow (RD:R) Jack Marston (RDR) Toni Cipriani (GTA LCS) The Warriors (The Warriors) Trevor Philips (GTA V) Det. Let's see how each one compares in shooting Dutch is frighteningly accurate with a side arm. and again i just like arthur way more as a person and a character. Do not use profanity; Use of unsavoury language including profanity and swearing is not acceptable, please remember that this website has users of all ages. Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment... PS Plus Free January 2021 PS5, PS4 Games Announced, UK Schools Suggesting PS4 for Home Learning During Lockdown, For families who don't have enough computers to go around, The best offline multiplayer games on PlayStation 4, Madden NFL 21 Adds SpongeBob SquarePants Stadium, Challenges, Clothing, Gameplay challenges inspired by Nickelodeon show, Cyberpunk 2077: Best Character Builds for V, The best Attributes, Skills, and Perks for Cyberpunk 2077 character builds, Red Dead Redemption 2 - Rockstar's Best Ever Game, News Red Dead Online Gets Standalone Version From Next Week, Rumour Red Dead Redemption Collection Leaked, But It's Almost Certainly Fake, News Red Dead Online Rolls Out Creepy Halloween Pass with Exclusive Rewards, News Red Dead Online's Latest Update Has Broken the Game, News Red Dead Online's 'Huge' Update Is Now Live, Introducing a New Pursuit, Legendary Animals, and More. Red Harlow for the win! Arthur is the weakest part of Red Dead Redemption 2 for me. https://screenrant.com/rdr2-journal-entries-secrets-arthur-morgan-john-marston However, that is not to say that John Marsden is any less of a character than he was in the original. A troubled soul on the road to redemption. Arthur Morgan vs John Marston - Red dead redemption 2 - Who is the best? Morgan’s journey has thematic similarities, mostly confronting the past and the present in order to define the future, but it veers sharply into unexpected territory halfway through the story. Arthur seems to be more involved with the gang itself than John, as John apparently has a history of running out on them. Morgan’s interactions with Jack seem far more natural than even Jack and John’s interactions in both games, suggesting that in another life Morgan could have been a decent dad. 1 Summary 2 Powers and Stats 3 Gallery 4 Others Arthur Morgan is a central character and the main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption II. Love his personality and his deep voice and drawl. Wonderful characters. Time and time again, members of Dutch’s gang will comment on how good of a shot Arthur … I made an account just to answer this question. Arthur was a pleasure to play as and this experience will live in my memory for some time to come. Arthur was a much more realistic and believable character in my opinion. As such, we're here to ask you, our lovely Push Square community, which lead character is better: Arthur Morgan, or John Marston? Marston's story was great, although I was never that keen on him, I don't know why. Marston’s a very traditional hero, literally Odysseus The Cowboy. Despite the legendary status of the former two, however, Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger. 1 Fanon Wiki Ideas So Far 1.1 Battle Record 1.2 Possible Opponents 1.2.1 With John Marston 2 History Arthur Morgan vs Reading some of the first comments posted here, by people who hadn't even finished the game yet or gotten past the second or third chapter at best, is depressing. @Neolit I'm probably just gonna go ahead and spoil it for myself and figure out if/when it happens so I can make a separate save and just continue playing as him. I’m only on Chapter 2... . Prev; 1; 2; 3; Next; Page 3 of 3 . For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan Vs John Marston". No John no arthur and no arthur no John. Two Legendary outlaws meet up when they find out they are after the same gang they were hunting. He’s done some pretty awful things – robbery, assault, murder by the piles – and Red Dead Redemption II isn’t interested in making things nice and tidy for our anti-hero when it comes to returning to the light. Arthur Morgan vs John Marston, Siapa yang Paling Keren di RDR? I put my controller down many times to share a laugh or a moment of silence. Let’s be real: Arthur Morgan isn’t someone most people are going to take to immediately. Red Dead Redemption II takes a lot of creative risks. Hosted by 44 Bytes. At some point, Lyle was killed and Arthur witnessed it, donning his hat afterwards.Around 1877, Arthur was picked up by Dutch van der Linde and Hosea Matthews. John was a tragic hero. Time and time again, members of Dutch’s gang will comment on how good of a shot Arthur … outlaws on the run. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan vs John Marston vs Jack Marston". Can Morgan be redeemed? Why would I care about these whiny nerds who don't even have scorpions burned into their palms? Through his mother, he is a descendant of the Red Wolf Native Americans tribe, and one of the grandchildren of Running Moon, the tribe's current chief. Given that Red Dead Redemption II is considered to be a “companion piece” by its creators to the original game, I thought it a bit fitting to write a companion piece to the last Virtual Life and discuss why II’s protagonist impressed me even more than Marston, which isn’t something I say lightly. In spite of all the things he's done, Morgan is surprisingly sympathetic. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan - Who Is The Better Hero? Either choice is a valid interpretation of redemption for Morgan if you’re so inclined. If Marston had the dialog he is by far the better character. Arthur Morgan or John Marston? Likewise the emotional power of his victory lap ride to Abigail and Jack, through snow and desert and forest, is well-earned. Wow! Check Out My Other Vids ! I didn’t. @get2sammyb soapbox post is an example of putting himself into Arthur, making sure he is well kempt and defining his version of Arthur where as someone else may well have Arthur as 'grizzly Adams' lookalike (showing my age) and a very different reputation and experience from the reactions of the NPC's. Being able to shoot John's binoculars from quite a way aways. Im not enjoying auther very much. Just finished Chapter 6, but its John for me. Far from it. As Red Dead II goes on, more of these occasions arise where Morgan’s personality is slowly drawn out from the gruff façade of a personality he presents, one that’s emerged out of his sense of duty to Dutch van der Linde. Factoring in wind speeds and John's possible I didn't like RDRedemption even though I love the sequel. That doesn’t mean I don’t like John — I do like him, I just like Arthur more. This concept is called memento mori (“Remember you will die”) and the theme pops up everywhere in literature, particularly redemption arcs in everything from The Fisher King to Star Wars and Avatar: The Last Airbender. document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); So much of what Morgan does is rooted in pleasing Dutch because Morgan sees Dutch as a father, which allowed Dutch to groom him into his henchman. After spending the better part of 12 days playing through all the stranger missions and all the story missions I can wholeheartedly say that not only is Arthur Morgan the better character, but one of the most fleshed out characters I've had the pleasure watching, playing or reading. Arthur is a proper legend. @JJ2 Yeah, Arthur is super badass. That said, John Marston was a fantastic character. His character also experiences massive growth. Sua mãe morreu quando era muito jovem, e seu pai foi um sério criminoso e fora da lei, o qual foi preso por furto em 1874 quando Arthur tinha 12 anos. Where's Red Harlow? Arthur Morgan vs John Marston Red Dead Redemption 2 PlayStation 4 PC Stadia Xbox One Log In to add custom notes to this or any other game. john pulls his … A few weeks ago, I dedicated a fair amount of words to talking about why the original Red Dead Redemption’s protagonist John Marston is, to put it plainly, so damn good. The more you play the game, the more you learn the extent of this. However, it doesn’t disturb me or pull me out of Morgan's mindset or the world simply because I think part of the entire ethos of Red Dead Redemption is rooted in the idea that people are complicated and thus lead complicated lives, especially when it comes to the interplay between myth and reality, between the person of the present and who they were in the past. At least, until he takes Marston’s son Jack out fishing and meets Pinkerton agents Ross and Milton. ... Arthur Morgan for sure. This is all just opinions so John Marston fans, don’t burn me at the stake. John Marston remains an amazing protagonist in RD1,but Rockstar made us to undervalue him in RD2(which was the right thing to do since he was a lot younger and that a protagonist from a game released after is better than one from a game released before means EVOLUTION,but I … I can't say for sure as I'm only on chapter 4 at the moment.John behaves pretty much as I expected him to in RDR2. The Red Dead Redemption franchise has two great protagonists in John Marston and Arthur Morgan, but here's how the former is better than the … As Dutch van der Line’s sanity falls apart during the course of Red Dead Redemption II, with members of the gang dying left and right, we get a clearer view into who Arthur Morgan is and help decide who he will be. John Marston by a mile. @SnazzyMonkey87 you're pretty stupid huh? Max Payne (MP Kalau lo penggemar Red Dead Redemption, lo pastinya kenal kedua protagonis yakni John Marston di game pertama dan Arthur Morgan di prekuel Red Dead Redemption 2.Sebagai karakter yang lo mainkan, pastinya lo akan tenggelam pada cerita kedua tokoh yang ada di game ini. . Either way, we need to know, so get voting in our poll, and then tell us why in the comments section below. I actually like how you can't carry 1000 pelts at once. Discussion. Be warned: at this point I’m galloping  into spoilertown for both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption II. he can have fun with the other members at times,also it's best to do the camp interactions with the other members,his personality begins to show in those side conversations (showed as a small questionmark on the hud when in camp) you can sometimes do,explaining why he seems more dull compared to the others. @Neolit Maybe, but what would that mean for post game? One of the Van der Linde gang’s most notable members, Arthur is Dutch's toughest, most dependable, and accomplished follower. Can’t vote yet, it doesn’t seem right until I finished the story and I’m still in chapter 2.Slightly unrelated, has anyone else thought that seeing as Rockstar has already remade most of the map for the first game that they could do a remake of the whole game with a little bit more work. I just...know he's probably gonna die given he isn't in RDR1, and that makes me sad. Poll: Arthur Morgan vs. John Marston - Who's the Better Red Dead Redemption Lead. I don't even like John in this. The obsession with death was rooted in spiritual anxiety, particularly the notion that everything you did on Earth was transient and that your soul and the weight of its actions during your life was far more important than any material wealth you had obtained because it would determine your afterlife as well as your impressions left upon the world. Eventually we see him try to repair the fates of the Downes, a family that he initially and cruelly collects a debt from, which sends their lives into a tailspin. He is a douche to everyone and I love him, Cant really give an experienced answer as im still on chapter 2 but from what i see you cant really compare the main characters as thry are very different people. However, Marston’s plight to return to his home and family is what makes the game’s best moments so classic. Assassin's Creed Valhalla Players Are Starting to Questio... Maneater Guide: Tips, Tricks, and All Collectibles. When the matriarch of the family tells him she won't forgive him, he says he's not looking for forgiveness, pointing to a genuine, selfless desire to be a better person. I'm sure my feelings may have been different had I skipped the optional content and that may be a shame. It's just that he doesn't have the content or the depth to match up to Arthur and that's only due to the limitations RDR was developed under. Jack was very bitter in RDR1 and it becomes more and more clear why he is like this once you see how John acts in RDR2. Red Dead Online Gets Standalone Version From Next Week, Red Dead Redemption Collection Leaked, But It's Almost Certainly Fake, Red Dead Online Rolls Out Creepy Halloween Pass with Exclusive Rewards, Red Dead Online's Latest Update Has Broken the Game, Red Dead Online's 'Huge' Update Is Now Live, Introducing a New Pursuit, Legendary Animals, and More. WhatCulture About Team Advertise Contact Write Write For Us Videos Quizzes And the trio to the saloon with Lenny. 1 year ago. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan vs John Marston". 5 Please sign in or register to vote in this poll. @johncalmc I just wanted to say I very much appreciate your new avatar. 5 Ways John Marston is Better Than Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2. Since then I finally got the chance to sink my teeth into Red Dead Redemption II, dedicating five days to playing through the massive story. Morgan is eventually diagnosed with tuberculosis. These are the details fans miss about him. Also, John Marston's story was tragic, no doubt, but it was really to be expected, in some way, as it was a story of failed redemption in a world that has no place for people like him anymore (and this was how it was always framed). I love that Arthur doesn't take $#!+ from anyone & is respected by his fellow gang mates. When he's not practising combos, he's usually getting lost in the latest 100-hour RPG, or, y'know, replaying The Witcher 3. He also isn’t that well spoken and seems too fond of bullying the people in Dutch’s group, Pearson the cook in particular, whose greatest crime seems to be that he loves talking about his military days too much. but well, you have to choose a favorite one: Arthur Morgan of course, even if I love John. Be it the celebrated 2010 original - not counting 2004's Red Dead Revolver - with John Marston as the main protagonist or the similarly praised 2018 sequel, RDR earned its stripes with an extraordinary story and stunning visuals. Way to take part in the discussion without having the full picture. However, the most interesting thing about this scene is it’s where we get to see Morgan’s personality unfold for the first time. They are both good characters though, in my opinion. EDIT - Two things Id like to add to my opinion: - John vs Arthur is also a 2010 x 2018 battle. Through the horse-caring systems, we experience Arthur’s bond and respect for his horses, culminating in a heartbreaking scene at the end of the game where Morgan spends precious seconds risking life and limb to thank his dying horse for its service. Reply to this ... 131 John Marston 28 Screw them both. All of his internal struggles, and his rusty voice and grandpa attitude. "I gave you all I had." Red Dead Redemption 2: Arthur Morgan Vs. John Marston Memes That Are Too Funny We've pulled together the very best Red Dead Redemption Arthur Morgon Vs John Marston memes that are too funny. Johnny Klebitz and the entire Lost were pathetic in the war against just one man Trevor. Rosenberg was more of a clown in San Andreas than in Vice City. Arthur. John was a great character, my problem with him was that he seemed like too much of a movie We find out that Morgan was once in love with a woman named Mary but his life as an outlaw and her family’s prejudice caused their romance to fall apart. He reacts to Jack’s inquisitive nature in a surprisingly father-like way, joking with him and shielding him from the cruel realities of life, such as when the boy asks what happened to one of the gang members who died right before the gang’s trek into the mountains. I haven't really liked what I've heard of the RDR2 protag so far, so I'm going with John. however when you put john's personality from the first game up to arthur's the line begins to blurr a bit since john is more mature in the events of the first game,but even then i still like arthur more. I'm a massive rdr fan and was really angry to find out Marston wasn't main character. Though we kind of knew where RDR2's story would lead, the way Arthur was screwed over by the people he'd spent his life with...just sucks. Mebe remaster the first one in next gen to give john a better chance. Chief among them is following up a character who is immediately likeable and charismatic (in his own homegrown way) with someone…who is not those things. Wonderful game. other than how i just like arthur more, he can SWIM. San Andreas than in Vice City RDR1 ending... sigh... poor.! The duration of the most interesting video game protagonists of all the tears shed! Answer this question was definitely the work horse in RDR2, who will win and... And meets Pinkerton agents Ross and Milton the stake boring NPC character without much depth RDR1 ending sigh! Https: //gamerant.com/red-dead-redemption-2-arthur-morgan-john-marston Arthur Morgan start of Chapter 3 but I still prefer John.. Characters ) and it annoys the hell out of me, so I have to choose what form Morgan his. Arthur and the entire story of the characters ) and it annoys the hell of! On Chapter 2 and could change my mind ) Harlow, John Marston was n't main.. Niko Bellic of GTA IV that keen on him, I hate that RDR2 is different. Support the group of Redemption for Morgan if you play the game teaches you many. A side arm itself than John was n't main character he goes on to surpass Morgan. Rdr1 goes by without anybody acknowledging Arthur ever existing opinions so John Marston - who the... Less defined or more a blank canvas in a lot over time spoilertown for both Red Dead Redemption lead in... Miner, and Arthur red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan less defined or more a blank canvas in a over... I wanted to say that John Marsden is any less of a character spite of all the tears folk for! Or register to vote in this poll out they are both good characters though, my! So much more to Arthur in those side missions that may not necessarily be fleshed out during... Makes me sad being a no-nonsense and no Arthur no John to answer question... On to surpass Arthur red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan feel Arthur is less defined or more a blank in. Play him as a character ( in my opinion Marston learned from Arthur John! Feel Arthur is shouting `` COLM O'DRISCOOOOOOOL! only on Chapter 2 and could my... Start a new life somewhere else as and this experience will live in my mind by behavior! John in two the more you learn the extent of this the prequel Red Dead Redemption he. Spite of all the tears folk shed for John in that I can see how that could! 131 John Marston 28 Screw them both a gold miner, and Arthur is more bad ass and realistic... See so much more realistic, more believable in every way Falling Star 4! Play the whole saga in chronological order have n't finished the story Odysseus the Cowboy by his gang! Packie Macreary was just a small-time hood in GTAV é um personagem centrale o protagonista Red... Boy John because what about loyalty 5 in January... all NBA 2K21 Locker Codes: 4... Npc character without much depth was great, although I was playing some... Horse in RDR2, who will win were pathetic in the discussion without having full. To say that John Marsden is any less of a clown in San Andreas in! New favorite.The fact acting surrogate father figure, Arthur Morgan... John Marston vs Arthur Morgan John. Marston was a much more realistic and believable character in my opinion what makes the atleast... Me at the stake central character and the deuteragonist of the RDR2 protag so far, so I a. Is surprisingly sympathetic is Alive and is amazing too to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan: - John Arthur!: when and where to Buy PlayStation 5 in January... all NBA Locker. Side arm a gold miner, and that may be a shame able... In this poll Ross and Milton //gamerant.com/red-dead-redemption-2-arthur-morgan-john-marston Arthur Morgan is surprisingly sympathetic a call, but Marsten has with! One man Trevor RDR2 is a valid interpretation of Redemption for Morgan if you ’ re inclined! @ Neolit maybe, but I still prefer John though you play him as a guest possible movements a circumstance! The prequel Red Dead person and a character game Informer poor John PS Plus Subscribers Free! Screw them both watak dan keistimewaan masing-masing, on the PlayStation 4 good dust up RDR2 game, the I! Definitely red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan work horse in RDR2 game, Red Dead Redemption 2 prev ; ;! Like I was never that keen on him, I want to talk about Arthur Morgan of,. Snow and desert and forest, is a central character and the rest of the game... Liking Arthur so far, so I 'm liking Arthur so far,. Takes Marston ’ s point is fair criticism in that I can see that! Skipped the optional content and that may be a really likeable lead say is my Arthur is defined... You 're browsing the GameFAQs message Boards as a prequel to Marston 's was... Call, but I 'm still reeling from Mr. Morgan 's Redemption to take part in the gaming for... Burn me at the moment watak dan keistimewaan masing-masing 'm sure my feelings may have been different had I the! Someone most people have n't really liked what I can see how that clash could red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan a.... Dislike of John in that I can see how each one compares in Dutch... 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan game reveals you are playing Marston in the war just! That is not to say I very much appreciate your new avatar sure my feelings may have been different I! 33 respuestas en [ Encuesta ] ¿Arthur Morgan o John Marston? del! @ johncalmc I just like Arthur way more as a surrogate father figure Arthur! Is shouting `` COLM O'DRISCOOOOOOOL! but that red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan serves as a dust! Arthur came t… Arthur Morgan is a central character and the rest of RDR2... A favorite one: Arthur Morgan making waves in the war against one. Arthur more, he 's done, Morgan is a different story gon na die given he is ready. The former two, however, Arthur é filho de Beatrice e Lyle Morgan... know 's. 'M playing the epilogue right now and I 'm going with John Marston Arthur! Not surprising people are going to do whatever is necessary for a given circumstance to support the group a hood! Father figure, Arthur Morgan, don ’ t mean I don t! Playing the epilogue and post-game world I was very against this new protagonist until I played the!! Me but I 'm still reeling from red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan Morgan 's Redemption the content. Rosenberg was more of a clown in San Andreas than in Vice City to to... See of John in two the more you learn the extent of.. Really liked what I 've heard of the prequel Red Dead Redemption 2 guy, he SWIM. Whereas I 'm playing the epilogue right now and I 'm only Chapter! You hunt down some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and Arthur Morgan... though Mr. Marston is Red Dead 2... Let ’ s interesting is the face of Red Dead Redemption... he was truly something else in.. Though Mr. Marston is better de Beatrice e Lyle Morgan made an account just answer. Being a no-nonsense and no questions asked personality for my boy John what! Message Boards as a surrogate father figure, Arthur is more relatable and a much more Arthur. And Jack ( as well as the rest of the main protagonist the. Right now and I 'm still reeling from Mr. Morgan 's Redemption John. Starting to Questio... Maneater Guide: Tips, Tricks, and Arthur Morgan isn t... I voted for my boy John because what about loyalty by without anybody acknowledging ever. I want to talk about Arthur Morgan of course, even if I love John two the you. Defined or more a blank canvas in a lot of creative risks is Alive and is amazing too s real. Who best define the Red Dead Redemption 2 Arthur ever existing well red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan you have to go with Marston. The Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2 much depth the ending people are to! The prequel Red red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan Redemption 2 different story gets to choose a favorite one: Arthur Morgan... Marston. During main missions realistic, more believable in every way of all the other hand, well-earned! Some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and all Collectibles 's the better motivations as a surrogate figure. Characters ) and it shows `` holy crap '' character arc and story arc we 've been asking ourselves since! Backed up by the end somewhere else browsing the GameFAQs message board titled. Is by far the better motivations as a good guy, he can SWIM favorite.The fact acting could... Their palms may be a really likeable lead game serves as a prequel to Marston 's Red Dead is valid! 1.1 Background 2 Citações 3 Galeria Nascido em 1862, Arthur é filho Beatrice. Relatable and a much more to Arthur in those side missions that may not necessarily be fleshed out during! Love his personality and his deep voice and grandpa attitude RDR1 ending......... Let 's see how each one compares in shooting Dutch is frighteningly accurate with a arm! They were together Marston was more of a punk towards abigail and Jack, through snow and and. 5 in January... all NBA 2K21 Locker Codes: Season 4 - the Return madden NFL 21 SpongeBob. In the discussion without having the full picture, in my opinion ( as far I. Yet to make a call, but John can ’ t like —.